The Differences between Mennonite and Amish Communities
Introduction
Mennonite and Amish communities are often confused with one another. These two religious groups have many similarities, such as their plain clothing and their beliefs in nonviolence and simplicity. However, they have some significant differences as well. This article will explore those differences.
History and Beliefs
The Mennonites and the Amish have a shared history. Both groups are Anabaptist, which means that they believe that baptism should only occur after a person has made a conscious decision to follow Jesus Christ. The Anabaptist movement began in the 16th century as a response to the corruption that was present in the Catholic Church at that time.
However, the Mennonites and the Amish began to diverge in the 1690s. The Amish wanted to maintain a strict separation from the rest of society, while the Mennonites believed that it was essential to engage with wider society.
Technology and Culture
The Amish community is known for its strict rejection of modern technology. They do not use electricity, telephones, or motorized vehicles. In contrast, the Mennonite community embraces modern technology, and many Mennonites have cars, televisions, and computers.
The Amish community is also known for its strict dress code. Men wear plain suits and trousers, and women wear dresses with aprons and bonnets. The Mennonite dress code is less strict, and clothing choices vary from one community to another.
Education
Education is also an area where the two communities differ. The Amish typically stop formal education after eighth grade, and they use their own schools to teach their children. In contrast, the Mennonite community places a high value on education, and many Mennonites attend college.
Conclusion
While the Mennonite and Amish communities share many similarities, they are also different in many ways. The Amish are known for their strict rejection of modern technology and strict dress code, while the Mennonites embrace modern technology and have a more relaxed approach to clothing. The Amish also have a different approach to education, while the Mennonites place a high value on learning.
In summary, the differences between the Mennonite and Amish communities are most significant in their approach to technology, culture, and education. People often confuse the two groups, but understanding these differences is crucial.
Table difference between mennonite and amish
| Factor | Mennonite | Amish |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | 16th century Switzerland | 17th century Switzerland and Alsace region of France |
| Beliefs | Similar to Protestant Christianity but with emphasis on pacifism and voluntary adult baptism | Similar to Mennonites but with added emphasis on separation from the world and use of horse-drawn transportation |
| Lifestyle | Generally more integrated with mainstream society, may use modern technology and dress in contemporary clothing | Generally more isolated from mainstream society, known for simple living, traditional dress, and use of horse-drawn transportation |
| Education | May attend public or private schools, emphasis on higher education and community involvement | Generally attend Amish-only schools up until eighth grade, limited formal education beyond that |
| Worship | May worship in traditional church buildings, emphasis on congregational involvement and diversity of worship styles | Worship in homes or barns, typically led by a bishop or minister, emphasis on simplicity and unity of worship |